Costco Pizza Ranked : Worst to Best List 2024

Costco Pizza Ranked : Worst to Best List 2024

Costco's food court has earned a dedicated fan base, and no item is more beloved than their pizza. But not all Costco pizzas are created equal. With three main types on the menu—Cheese, Pepperoni, and Combo—you might wonder which one deserves your attention. We’ve tasted them all, and here’s our official ranking of Costco pizzas, from worst to best, for 2024.

Costco Pizza Ranked : Worst to Best List 2024

3. Cheese Pizza: A Classic but Basic

Costco Kirkland Signature 6T5H P180 Cheese Pizza Same-Day Delivery | Costco  Canada

Costco’s cheese pizza has its merits—it’s large, affordable, and absolutely loaded with cheese. In fact, each pizza boasts a three-cheese blend of mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan, spread generously over Costco’s signature thick crust. The cheese pizza is a great option for those who prefer a simpler, no-frills slice.

However, it falls to third place because it can be a bit one-dimensional. If you’re a pizza lover who craves complexity, the cheese pizza might leave you wanting more. While it’s still a solid choice, especially for families with picky eaters, its lack of toppings can make it feel a little too basic compared to the other offerings.

Why it's ranked last:

  • Pros: Great for cheese lovers, consistent in quality, affordable.
  • Cons: No variety in flavor, lacks excitement.

2. Pepperoni Pizza: A Meaty Classic

Kirkland Signature Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza, 4 ct (4 ct) Delivery or  Pickup Near Me - Instacart

Moving up in the rankings is the pepperoni pizza, a fan favorite for a reason. Costco’s pepperoni pizza doesn’t skimp on the toppings—it’s absolutely covered in delicious, crispy pepperoni slices. The pizza is also known for its perfect cheese-to-pepperoni ratio, making sure every bite is balanced.

Pepperoni adds that needed kick of flavor, and the slightly greasy but satisfying pepperoni slices are crispy around the edges. Whether you’re looking for something quick after a shopping spree or hosting a casual pizza night at home, Costco’s pepperoni pizza delivers.

However, it’s not the top choice simply because it’s still a relatively standard offering. While it hits all the right notes, it doesn’t have the “wow factor” that makes it stand out from other pizzas.

Why it's ranked second:

  • Pros: Generous pepperoni, balanced flavors, perfect for meat lovers.
  • Cons: It’s great, but nothing you haven’t had before.

1. Combo Pizza: The King of Costco Pizzas

How to Order Costco Pizza - Costco97.com

At the top of the list for 2024 is Costco’s Combo Pizza, a true heavyweight in the pizza world. Loaded with everything you could want—pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and olives—this pizza packs a punch. It’s like a supreme pizza on steroids.

The combination of meats and veggies, all layered over a cheesy base, gives this pizza the variety and depth that the other options lack. Each bite offers a different flavor explosion, with the savory sausage pairing perfectly with the crisp vegetables. It’s also worth noting that Costco’s crust can handle all these toppings without becoming soggy, making for a hearty, satisfying slice.

The combo pizza is the ultimate choice for Costco pizza lovers because it offers the best of everything in one pie. Whether you're a meat lover or someone who appreciates a good veggie topping, the combo pizza checks all the boxes. It’s indulgent, filling, and absolutely delicious.

Why it’s ranked first:

  • Pros: Loaded with toppings, rich in flavor, balanced with meats and veggies.
  • Cons: None—this is the pizza that does it all.

Final Thoughts

While Costco’s pizza menu may be limited to three main types, each one brings something unique to the table. Whether you’re in the mood for the simplicity of a cheese pizza, the savory kick of pepperoni, or the full-flavored experience of the combo, there’s something for every pizza lover.

2024 Ranking Recap:

  1. Combo Pizza – The best in flavor and variety.
  2. Pepperoni Pizza – A meat lover’s favorite, simple and satisfying.
  3. Cheese Pizza – Classic, but could use more excitement.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. How much is Costco pizza?
Costco pizzas are priced at $9.95 for a whole 18-inch pizza, regardless of the type. You can also buy a large slice for around $1.99.

2. Can you customize Costco pizza?
Costco’s food court typically sticks to its set pizza options without much room for customization. However, some locations may accommodate special requests.

3. Is Costco combo pizza still available?
As of 2024, Costco’s combo pizza remains on the menu in most locations, though it was temporarily unavailable during certain times in previous years.

4. Can non-members buy Costco pizza?
In some locations, you need to be a Costco member to purchase food from the food court, but certain locations with food courts outside the store may serve non-members.

Back to blog